«ANGEVIN», «NORMAN», «ENGLISH», «AQUITANIAN» «EMPIRES», OR «COMPOSITE MONARCHIES» IN MEDIEVAL EUROPE
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.15330/gal.39.78-109Keywords:
medieval state, «Angevin Empire», «Norman Empire», «First English Empire», «Plantagenet lands / Plantagenet space», composite monarchy, personal union, dominiumAbstract
The article offers a new interpretation of the so‑called Angevin, Norman, Aquitanian, and English empires as composite monarchies. The originality of the study lies in the deconstruction of established historiographical mythologemes and a critical reassessment of the applicability of the concepts of «state» and «empire» to the realities of the 11th–13th centuries. The aim of the article is to reconstruct the structure and mechanisms of functioning of the Angevin dynasty’s possessions and to determine their correspondence to the concepts of a «composite monarchy» and personal union. The methodology is based on the principles of historical constructivism, comparative and structural analysis, as well as approaches from the new political history and intellectual history. The main results show that medieval power was exercised over people rather than territories; royal authority functioned as a form of seigneurial power, while political formations were composite, with fluid configurations of rights and loyalties. As a result, it is demonstrated that the Plantagenet possessions constituted a network of personal and familial ties rather than a coherent «state» in the modern sense. The research prospects include expanding comparative studies to Ukrainian material and rethinking the concept of the «Romanovych state» in terms of a personal union. The practical significance lies in refining the categorical apparatus of Ukrainian medieval studies and critically examining the influence of modern political concepts on the interpretation of the past.
References
Abrams, Р. (1988). Notes on the Difficulty of Studying the State (1977). Journal of Historical Sociology, 1 (1), 58–89 (in English).
Althoff, G. (1990). Verwandte, Freunde und Getreue: zum politischen Stellenwert der Gruppenbindungen im früheren Mittelalter. Darmstadt : Wissenschaftliche Buchgesellschaft. 237 p. (in German).
Althoff, G. (2003). Otto III / trans. P. G. Jestice. Pennsylvania : State University Press. 215 p. (in English).
Anderson, A. O. (Ed.). (1908). Scottish Annals from English Chroniclers. London : D. Nutt. xiii, 403 p. (in English).
Arnold, E. T. (Ed.). (1885). Symeonis monachi opera omnia. Historia regum. Eadem historia ad quintum et vicesimum annum continuata, per Joannem Hagulstadensem. Accedunt varia. Vol. II. London : Longman, Trübner etc. xli+446 p. (in Latin).
Aurell, M. (2002). L’Empire des Plantagenêt, 1154–1224. Paris : Perrin. 406 p. (in French).
Bachrach, B. S. (1978). Idea of the Angevin Empire. Albion: A Quarterly Journal Concerned with British Studies, 10 (4), 293–299. https://doi.org/10.2307/4048161 (in English).
Barlow, F. (1999). The Feudal Kingdom of England, 1042–1216. 5th ed. Harlow, UK : Pearson Education. 416 p. (in English).
Barrow, G. W. S. (1957). A Writ of Henry II for Dumfermline Abbey. Scottish Historical Review. Vol. 36. Р. 138–143 (in English).
Bates, D. (1989). Normandy and England after 1066. The English Historical Review. Vol. CIV (413). Р. 851–880. https://doi.org/10.1093/ehr/CIV.413.851 (in English).
Bautier R.-H. (1986). Conclusions. «Empire Plantagenêt» ou «espace Plantagenêt». Y eut-il une civilisation du monde Plantagenêt? Cahiers de Civilisation Médiévale. Vol. 29. P. 139–147 (in French).
Bell, A. (Ed.). (1960). L’Estoire des Engleis by Geffrei Gaimar. Oxford : Blackwell, 1960. lxxxiv + 307 p. (in French).
Blincoe, M. E. (2015). Geoffrey le Bel of Anjou and Political Inheritance in the Anglo-Norman Realm. The Haskins Society Journal. Vol. 27. P. 79–100. https://doi.org/10.1017/9781782048664.006 (in English).
Blincoe, M. E. (2019). Political Identity and the Succession of Henry II. The Haskins Society Journal. Vol. 31. P. 163–184. https://doi.org/10.1017/9781800101159.009 (in English).
Brewer, J. S. et al. (Ed.). (1861). Giraldi Cambrensis opera. Vol. VIII. London : Longman, Green, Longman, & Roberts. lxvii, 432 p. (in Latin).
Chartrou, J. (1928). L’Anjou de 1109 à 1151. Paris : Les Presses universitaires de France. 442 p. (in French).
Chepizhenko, V. V. (2017). Vizualizatsiia vlady: symvolika «Viltonskoho dyptykhu» ta sakralizatsiia obrazu monarkha. Text and Image: Essential Problems in Art History. Vol. 1. S. 61–69 (in Ukrainian).
Chepizhenko, V. V. (2024). «Ta shcho imia?»: do problemy poshuku ukrainskykh vidpovidnykiv zakhidnoievropeiskykh serednovichnykh antroponimiv. Ukrainska istoriia u publichnomu prostori: Proceedings of the 2nd International Scientific-Practical Conference. Lviv ; Toruń : Liha-Pres. S. 114–118 (in Ukrainian).
Chibnall, M. (Ed. and trans.). (1969). The Ecclesiastical History of Orderic Vitalis. Vol. IІ: Books ІII and ІV. Oxford : Clarendon Press. 456 p. (in Latin & English).
Chibnall, M. (Ed. and trans.). (1973). The Ecclesiastical History of Orderic Vitalis. Vol. IV: Books VII and VIII. Oxford : Clarendon Press. 435 p. (in Latin & English).
Chibnall, M. (Ed. and trans.). (1978). The Ecclesiastical History of Orderic Vitalis. Volume VІ: Books XI, XII, and XIII. Oxford : Clarendon Press. 650 p. (in Latin & English).
Chibnall, M. (1991), The Empress Matilda: Queen Consort, Queen Mother and Lady of the English. London, UK : Basil Blackwell. 227 p. (in English).
Chibnall, M. (2004). England and Normandy 1042–1137. The New Cambridge Medieval History, Vol. 4: c.102 –c.1198, Part 2 / ed. by D. Luscombe, Jonathan Riley-Smith. Cambridge : Cambridge University Press. P. 191–216. https://doi.org/10.1017/CHOL9780521414111.009 (in English).
Church, S. D. (2023). The ‘Angevin Empire’ (1150–1204): A twelfth-century union. Unions and Divi-sions: New Forms of Rule in Medieval and Renaissance Europe / ed. by P. Srodecki, N. Kersken, R. Petrauskas. London ; New York : Routledge. doi: 10.4324/9781003199007-7. P. 68–82 [in English].
Clanchy, M. T. (1983). England and its Rulers, 1066–1272: Foreign Lordship and National Identity. Totowa, N. J. : Barnes & Noble Books. 320 p. (in English).
Crouch, D. B. (1994). The March and the Welsh Kings. The Anarchy of King Stephen’s Reign / ed. Edmund King. Oxford : Clarendon Press. P. 255–289. (in English).
Davis, H. W. C. (Ed.). (1913). Regesta regum Anglo-Normannorum, 1066–1154. Vol. I: Regesta Willelmi Conquestoris et Willelmi Rufi, 1066–1100. Oxford : Clarendon Press. xliii+159 p. (in Latin).
Davis, H. W. C. (Ed.). (1913). Regesta regum Anglo-Normannorum, 1066–1154. Vol. III: Regesta Regis Stephani ac Mathildis Imperatricis ac Gaufridi et Henrici Ducum Normannorum, 1135–1154. Oxford : Clarendon Press. lii+422 p. (in Latin).
Davis, R. H. C. (1977). King Stephen. 1st ed. London : Longman. 178 p. (in English).
Davies, R. R. (1987). The Age of Conquest: Wales, 1063–1415. Oxford : Oxford University Press. xiii, 530 p. (in English).
Davies, R. R. (2000). The First English Empire. Power and Identities in the British Isles 1093–1343. Oxford : Oxford University Press, 2000. 213 p. [in English].
Davies, R. R. (2003). The Medieval State: The Tyranny of a Concept? Journal of Historical Sociology, 16 (2), 280–300 (in English).
Debord, A. (1992). The Castellan Revolution and the Peace of God in Aquitaine. The peace of god: Social violence and religious response in France around the year 1000 / eds. T. F. Head, & R. A. Landes. Ithaca, New York : Cornell University Press. P. 135–164 (in English).
Delisle, M. L., Bouquet M. (Eds.). (1871). Recueil des historiens des Gaules et de la France. Tome VIII. Paris : Victor Palmé. clxviii, 787 p. (in Latin).
Delisle, M. L., Bouquet M. (Eds.). (1874). Recueil des historiens des Gaules et de la France. Tome IX. Paris : Victor Palmé. cxxxiv, 882 p. (in Latin).
Delisle, M. L., Bouquet M. (Eds.). (1877). Recueil des historiens des Gaules et de la France. Tome XII. Paris : Victor Palmé. lvi, 1013 p. (in Latin).
Downer, L. J. (ed.). (1972). Leges Henrici Primi. Oxford : Clarendon Press. 460 p. [in Latin].
Dunbabin, J. (1985). France in the Making, 843–1180. Oxford ; New York : Oxford University Press. x, 442 p. (in English).
Duncan, A. A. M. (1958). The Earliest Scottish Charters. Scottish History Review. Vol. 37. P. 103–135 (in English).
Dvolitka, V. (Comp.). (2009). Halytsko-Volynska derzhava: istoriia, postati, kultura : bibliohr. pokazhch. Ivano-Frankivsk. 64 s. (in Ukrainian).
Edwards, E. (Ed.). (2012). Chronica Monasterii de Hida juxta Wintoniam, in Liber Monasterii de Hyda. Cambridge University Press. P. 283–321 (in Latin).
Elliott, J. H. (1992). A Europe of Composite Monarchies. Past & Present. Vol. 137. P. 48–71 (in English).
Fanning, S., Bachrach, B. S. (eds. & trans.). (2011). The Annals of Flodoard of Reims, 916–966. New York ; Ontario : University of Toronto Press. 128 p. (in English).
Foot, S. (2011). Æthelstan: The First King of England. New Haven, US : Yale University Press. 283 p. (in English).
Flori, J. (2004). Aliénor d'Aquitaine : la reine insoumise. Paris : Payot. 543 p. (in French).
Gierke, O. von. (1873). Das deutsche Genossenschaftsrecht. Vol. 2: Geschichte des deutschen Korperschaftsbegriff. Berlin : Weidmannsche Buchandlung. 976 p. (in German).
Gierke, O. (1900). Political Theories of the Middle Ages / trans. F. W. Maitland. Cambridge UP : Cambridge. 138 p. (in English).
Gilbert, J. T. (Ed.). (1870). Historical and Municipal Documents of Ireland, 1172–1320. London : Longmans, Green. lxxxviii, 560 p. (in Latin).
Gillingham, J. (1984). The Angevin Empire. London : Edward Arnold. 1st ed. 112 p. (in English).
Gillingham, J. (2001). The Angevin empire. 2nd ed. London : Arnold ; New York : Oxford University Press. 148 p. [in English].
Gillingham, J. (2007). Doing homage to the king of France. Henry II: New Interpretations / ed. C. Har-per-Bill and N. Vincent. Woodbridge : Boydell & Brewer. P. 63–84 (in English).
Hagger, M. (2017). Norman rule in Normandy, 911–1144. Woodbridge : The Boydell Press. xviii, 798 p. (in English).
Halphen, L., Poupardin R. (Eds.). (1913). Historia Gaufredi, ducis Normannorum et comitis Ande¬ga-vorum, in Chroniques des comtes d’Anjou et des seigneurs d’Amboise. Paris : A. Picard. Р. 227–310. (in Latin).
Hamilton, H. C. (Ed.). (1856). Historia rerum anglicarum Willelmi Parvi, Ordinis Sancti Augustini canonici regularis in Cœnobio Beatæ Mariæ de Newburgh in agro Eboracensi. Vol. 1. Londini, sumptibus Societatis. xii, 288 p. (in Latin).
Hardy, T. D. (Ed.). (1840). Willelmi Malmesbiriensis monachi Gesta regum Anglorum, atque Historia novella. Vol. II. Londini : sumptibus Societatis. P. 389–816 (in Latin).
Haskins, Ch. H. (1912). Normandy under Geoffrey Plantagenet. The English Historical Review, XXVII, 417–444. https://doi.org/10.1093/ehr/XXVII.CVII.417 (in English).
Haskins, Ch. H. (1915). The Norman in European History. Boston et New York : Houghton Mif in Company, 1915. 258 p. (in English).
Helmerichs, R. (2001 for 1997). Princeps, Dux, Comes Normannorum : Early Rollonid Titles and Their Significance. Haskins Society Journal. Vol. 9. P. 57–77 (in English).
Hollister, C. W., Keefe, T. K. (1973). The Making of the Angevin Empire. Journal of British Studies. Vol. 12 (2). P. 1–25 (in English).
Hollister, C. W. (1976). Normandy, France and the Anglo-Norman regnum. Speculum. Vol. 51 (2). P. 202–242 (in English).
Holt, J. C. (1972). Politics and Property in Medieval England. Past & Present. Vol. 57 (1). P. 3–52. https://doi.org/10.1093/past/57.1.3 (in English).
Holt, J. C. (1975). The End of the Anglo-Norman Realm. Proceedings of the British Academy. Vol. 61. P. 223–265 (in English).
Horobets, V. M., Voloshchuk, M. M., Plakhonin, A. H., Cherkas, B. V., Halushko, K. Yu. (2016). Rus «pislia Rusi». Mizh koronoiu i bulavoiu. Ukrainski zemli vid korolivstva Rusi do Viiska Zaporozkoho. Kharkiv : Family Leisure Club. S. 71–90 (in Ukrainian).
Houts, E. van. (Ed. and trans.). (2000). The Normans in Europe. Manchester : Manchester University Press. xi, 308 p. (in English).
Hrushevskyi, M. (1905). Halytsko-Volodymyrska derzhava (XIII–XIV v.). Istoriia Ukrainy-Rusy. T. III: do roku 1340. 2nd ed. L’viv : Drukarnia Naukovoho tovarystva imeni Shevchenka. S. 1–142 (in Ukrainian).
Hudáček, P. (2014). Kráľovstvo, monarchia alebo štát? (K otázke používania konceptu štátu v ranom stredoveku). Forum Historiae. Vol. 8(2): Moc a štát v stredovekej Európe. S. 1–44 (in Slovak).
Humetska, L. L., Kernytskyi, I. M. (Eds.). (1977). Slovnyk staroukrainskoi movy XIV–XV st.: u 2 t. T. 1: A–M. Kyiv : Scientific Thought. 632 s. (in Ukrainian).
James, P., Nairn, T. (2006). Globalization and Violence. London : Sage Publications. 1784 p. (in English).
Keefe, T. K. (1974). Geoffrey Plantagenet’s Will and the Angevin Succession. Albion: A Quarterly Journal Concerned with British Studies. Vol. 6 (3). P. 266–274. (in English).
Kienast, W. (1968). Der Herzogstitel in Frankreich und Deutschland. Munich : Oldenbourg. 505 s. (in German).
King, E. (2010). King Stephen. New Haven : Yale University Press. xvii + 382 p. (in English).
Koenigsberger, H. G. (1978). Monarchies and Parliaments in Early Modern Europe: Dominium Regale or Dominium Politicum et Regale. Theory and Society. Vol. 5 (1). P. 191–217 (in English).
Lair, J. (ed.). (1865). Dudonis Sancti Quintini, De moribus et actis primorum Normanniæ ducum. Mémoires de la Société des Antiquaires de Normandie. Vol. 23. Pt. 2. Caen : F. Le Blanc-Hardel. 329 p. (in Latin).
Le Patourel, J. (1965). The Plantagenet Dominions. History. Vol. 50 (170). P. 289–308. https://doi.org/ 10.1111/j.1468-229X.1965.tb01148.x (in English).
Le Patourel, J. (1971) Normandy and England 1066–1144 (The Stenton Lecture 1970). University of Reading, 1971. 38 p. (in English).
Le Patourel, J. (1976). The Norman Empire. Oxford : Clarendon Press. x + 416 р. [in English].
Lugovyi O. (2020). Empire. Glossary. Past / Future / Art. URL : https://pastfutureart.org/en/glossary/ (in English).
Madeline, F. (2008). L’empire des Plantagenêts. Espace féodal et construction territoriale. Hypothèses. Vol. 11 (1). P. 239–252. (in French).
Madeline, F. (2014). Les Plantagenêts et leur empire : Construire un territoire politique. Rennes : Presses universitaires de Rennes. 368 p. (in French).
Madeline, F. (2021). How to map the Angevin Empire? HAL Id: hal-03462760 (in English).
Marchegay, P., Salmon, A. (Eds.). (1871). Chroniques des Comtes d’Anjou. Paris : J. Renouard. 180 p. (in French).
Marchegay, P., Salmon, A. (Eds.). (2011). Fragmentum Historiae Andegavensis, in: Chroniques d'Anjou, Vol. 1. Cambridge : University Press. P. 373–384. (in Latin).
Mayer, T. (1935). Der Staat der Herzoge von Zähringen. Freiburg i. Brsg. : Wagner. 31 (in German).
Mayer, H. E. (1985). The Succession to Baldwin II of Jerusalem: English Impact on the East. Dumbarton Oak Papers. Vol. 39. P. 139–147. doi:10.2307/1291522 (in English).
McNair, F. (2020). Political culture and ducal authority in Aquitaine, c. 900–1040. History Compass. Vol. 18 (8). https://doi.org/10.1111/hic3.12622 (in English).
Migne, J.-P. (ed.). (1855). Patrologiae Latinae cursus completes. Vol. 179. 1888 p. (in Latin).
Muir, R. (1911). Philips’ New Historical Atlas for Students. London : G. Philip & Son. 96 p. (in English).
Norgate, K. (1887). England Under the Angevin Kings, 2 vols. Vol 2. London : Macmillan & Co. 521 p. (in English).
O’Neill, D. I. (2025). Empire. Encyclopedia Britannica. URL : https://www.britannica.com/topic/empire-political-science. (in English).
Plant, J. S. (2007). The Tardy Adoption of the Plantagenet Surname. Nomina. Vol. 30. P. 57–84. (in English).
Poole, A. L. (1955). Domesday Book to Magna Carta. (The Oxford History of England, vol. 3). Oxford : Oxford University Press. 2nd ed. xv, 541 p. (in English).
Power D. (2016). Angevin (Plantagenet) Empire. The Encyclopedia of Empire / eds N. Dalziel and J. M. MacKenzie. John Wiley & Sons, Ltd. Published. https://doi.org/10.1002/9781118455074.wbeoe084 (in English).
Ramsay, J. (1903). The Angevin Empire, or the Reigns of Henry II, Richard I and John (1154–1216). Oxford : Oxford University Press. 556 p. (in English).
Reimitz, H. (2015). History, Frankish Identity and the Framing of Western Ethnicity, 550–850. Cambridge : University Press. 528 p. (in English).
Reynolds, S. (1997). Kingdoms and Communities in Western Europe, 900–1300. Oxford : Clarendon Press ; New York : Oxford University Press. lxxv, 387 p. (in English).
Reynolds, S. (2003). There were States in Medieval Europe: A Response to Rees Davies. Journal of Historical Sociology. Vol. 16 (4). P. 550–555 (in English).
Richardson, H. G., Sayles, G. O. (1963). The Governance of Mediaeval England from the Conquest to Magna Carta. Edinburgh : University Press. ix, 514 p. (in English).
Ritchie, R. L. G. (1954). The Normans in Scotland. Edinburgh : University Press. xliv, 466 p. (in English).
Skinner, Q. (1995). The State. Political innovation and conceptual change / eds. T. Ball, J. Farr, R. L. Hanson. Cambridge : Cambridge University Press. P. 90–131 (in English).
Steindorf, L. (2023). Unions as a Structural Element: Preconditions, Intentions and Realisations. Unions and Divisions: New Forms of Rule in Medieval and Renaissance Europe / ed. by P. Srodecki, N. Kersken, R. Pet¬rauskas. London and New York : Routledge. P. 33–39 (in English).
Taagepera, R. (1979). Size and Duration of Empires: Growth-Decline Curves, 600 B. C. to 600 A.D. Social Science History, 3 (3/4), 115–138. https://doi.org/10.2307/1170959 (in English).
Turner, R. V. (2009). Eleanor of Aquitaine: Queen of France, Queen of England. New Haven, CT : Yale University Press. 416 p. (in English).
Turner, R. V. (2009). King John: England’s Evil King? Stroud, UK : History Press. 240 p. (in English).
Voloshchuk, M. (2018). Movoiu dzherel? Terminolohichni aspekty istoriohrafichnoho derzhavonai¬me-nuvannia na prykladi Halytskoi zemli Х–XIV st. Colloquia Russica, Series II, vol. 4: Serednovichna Rus: problemy terminolohii. Ivano-Frankivsk ; Krakow, р. 265–295 (in Ukrainian).
Warren, W. L. (1973). Henry II. New Haven : Yale University Press. 693 p. (in English).
Warren, W. L. (1991). King John. London : Methuen. 350 p. (in English).
Werner, K.-F. (1976). Quelques observations au sujets des débuts du “duché” de normandie. Droit privé et institutions régionales: etudes historiques offertes à Jean Yver. Paris : Presses universitaires de Rouen et du Havre. P. 691–709 (in French).
Winkler, E. A. (2022). Æthelflaed and Other Rulers in English Histories, c.900–1150. The English Historical Review, 137 (587), 969–1002, https://doi.org/10.1093/ehr/ceac178 (in English).
Wyon, A., Wyon, A. B. (Eds.). (1887). The Great Seals of England: from the earliest period to the pre-sent time: arranged and illustrated with descriptive and historical notes. London : Elliot Stock. 217 p. (in English).
